Miami Beach commissioners voted 7-0 Wednesday to sue Florida over a law that lets owners tear down some oceanfront buildings. The Savoy and the Arlington are the test.
The Miami Beach City Commission has told the city attorney to sue the state of Florida over a 2024 law that limits the city’s power to stop some oceanfront buildings from being torn down.
Commissioners approved the resolution Wednesday, 7-0. It names two Ocean Drive hotels the city wants to save: the Savoy, built in 1937 at 425 Ocean Drive, and the Arlington, built in 1941 at 445 Ocean Drive.
The item, C7 AX, sat on the consent agenda. No commissioner pulled it for debate, so it passed in the single vote that approved the consent agenda, the meeting’s video transcript shows.
What the commission approved
The final wording on the Nov. 18 agenda was revised Nov. 12. It does three things:
- directs City Attorney Ricardo J. Dopico to file a lawsuit on the “viable legal challenges” his office has found to the law
- says the aim is to save the Savoy, the Arlington and other contributing and architecturally significant buildings from demolition
- lets him hire specialized outside lawyers, with a budget amendment later “if necessary”
Vice Mayor Alex Fernandez and Commissioner Tanya K. Bhatt sponsored it.
A companion resolution, C7 AP, passed in the same vote. It urges the Florida Legislature to repeal the law, or to change it so it protects buildings that are individually designated or sit in local or national historic districts. The city clerk will send it to the South Florida legislative delegation, the Miami-Dade County mayor and commission, and neighboring cities, the agenda says.
The law and the two hotels
The law is Section 553.8991 of the Florida Statutes, the Resiliency and Safe Structures Act. It bars cities from restricting the demolition or rebuilding of certain buildings seaward of the coastal construction control line. A building qualifies if it falls short of current flood elevation rules, has been found unsafe or has been ordered demolished.
The owner of the Savoy and the Arlington has invoked the law in an application for a new project that would demolish both buildings, the draft resolution says. Both hotels are contributing buildings in the Ocean Beach Local Historic District. The law’s tests and exemptions were set out before the vote.
The Miami Design Preservation League spoke for the items during public comment. A speaker for the group, which is based at 1001 Ocean Drive, said it supported all four agenda items on the state’s Live Local Act and the Safe Structures Act, according to the transcript.
What is still unknown
The city has not said:
- when the suit will be filed, or in which court
- which legal grounds it will argue
- which outside law firm it will hire, or what the case will cost
The agenda memo listed the fiscal impact as “N/A.” The city had issued no news release on the vote by Friday evening, and the clerk’s minutes for the meeting were not yet posted.
What it means for you
- If you own a building near the ocean: the city’s historic property viewer shows whether it is in a historic district. The Planning Department is at 305-673-7550.
- Watch the meeting: the full Nov. 18 meeting is on the city’s Swagit video page.
- Next step: the resolution sets no deadline for filing the suit.
Have your say