Commissioners vote Nov. 18 on suing Florida over a 2024 law that lets owners tear down some oceanfront buildings. The Savoy and Arlington's owner has invoked it.
The Miami Beach City Commission will vote Wednesday, Nov. 18, on whether to sue the state of Florida over a 2024 law that strips the city of its power to stop some oceanfront buildings from being torn down.
The resolution names two Ocean Drive hotels it aims to save: the Savoy, built in 1937 at 425 Ocean Drive, and the Arlington, built in 1941 at 445 Ocean Drive. The owner of both properties has invoked the law in an application for a new project on the site. That project would demolish both buildings, the draft resolution says.
The item, C7 AX, would approve “the filing of a lawsuit based on the viable legal challenges” that City Attorney Ricardo J. Dopico has identified. It would also let him hire specialized outside lawyers, with a budget amendment later if one is needed. Vice Mayor Alex Fernandez is the sponsor.
What the state law does
The law is Section 553.8991 of the Florida Statutes, known as the Resiliency and Safe Structures Act. The Legislature passed it in 2024.
It bars cities from putting restrictions or conditions on the demolition or rebuilding of a qualifying building. A building qualifies if it sits seaward of the coastal construction control line and meets one of these tests:
- it does not meet current base flood elevation rules
- a local building official has found it unsafe
- it has been ordered demolished
The law exempts some buildings. They are:
- buildings individually listed on the National Register of Historic Places
- single-family homes
- contributing buildings in a historic district that was on the National Register before Jan. 1, 2000
A companion resolution from Fernandez, item C7 AP, spells out what the city says is at stake. It says the law “potentially places hundreds of historic buildings and structures in the City” at risk of demolition. For those buildings there would be no certificate of appropriateness, no hearing before the Historic Preservation Board and no rule that the old building be kept or replicated, the companion resolution says.
That resolution asks the Legislature to repeal the law, or to amend it so it protects buildings in local and national historic districts. It would be sent to the South Florida legislative delegation, the Miami-Dade County mayor and commission, and neighboring cities.
Why the Savoy and the Arlington
Both hotels are contributing buildings in the Ocean Beach Local Historic District, which the city designated in 1996. The National Park Service recognized it as a Certified Local District in 2004, according to the resolution.
The resolution describes the two hotels as “architecturally significant examples of Miami Beach’s Art Deco and Classical Revival style of architecture.” It says they show the low-scale massing, streamlined forms and “strong relationship between architecture, landscape, and the Atlantic Ocean” of the city’s Art Deco heritage.
The city’s legal argument rests partly on federal law. Miami Beach has been a Certified Local Government under the National Historic Preservation Act since May 14, 2002. That status requires a local review process for demolitions of historic properties. The resolution says the state law “may impair the City’s ability to conduct historic preservation activities” under the federal act.
What the agenda does not say
Neither memo gives the legal grounds the city attorney has found, an estimate of what the lawsuit would cost or which court it would be filed in. Both list the fiscal impact as “N/A.” The resolution does not name the owner or say when the demolition application was filed.
Both items are listed on the consent agenda, under resolutions.
What it means for you
- Watch or speak: the meeting starts at 8:30 a.m. Wednesday, Nov. 18, in the Commission Chamber at City Hall, 1700 Convention Center Drive. It is also on Zoom, webinar ID 813 9285 7671, or by phone at 888-475-4499. The items are C7 AX and C7 AP on the Nov. 18 agenda.
- Does your building qualify? The law covers buildings seaward of the coastal construction control line. The city’s historic property viewer shows whether a building is in a historic district. For questions, the Planning Department is at 305-673-7550.
- Next step: if commissioners approve, the city attorney can file suit. The resolution sets no deadline for doing so.
Have your say