The owner of the 226-room Stanton at 161 Ocean Drive wants to replace it with a 145-foot residential tower. The preservation board hears the plan Dec. 15.

Overview

The owner of the Stanton hotel at 161 Ocean Drive has asked the city to let it tear down the 10-story, 226-room hotel and build a 27-unit residential tower in its place. The 1939 building on the corner, known as The Stanton, would stay. The Historic Preservation Board is scheduled to hear the plan at 9 a.m. Tuesday, Dec. 15.

What the owner wants to build

The application, HPB26-0697, was filed by Komar Investments LLC, which its lawyers describe as the owner of the property. Their letter of intent to the board, dated Oct. 4 sets out the plan.

The letter says the project would:

  • replace the 226-room hotel with a new building of 27 residential units
  • rise to 145 feet
  • keep and restore the Ocean Drive front of the two-story historic building
  • partly demolish and rebuild that building’s north side to make an entrance facing the park
  • use part of the historic building as small commercial space opening onto Ocean Drive
  • cut the driveways onto the street from three to two

The site covers 1.41 acres on the ocean side of Ocean Drive. The Ocean House condominium is to the south. To the north is an unbuilt stretch of Second Street and then Marjory Stoneman Douglas Ocean Beach Park. The letter says the tower was designed by Olson Kundig, an architecture firm based in Seattle.

The city’s cover memo for the item describes it as the total demolition of a 10-story hotel that does not count toward the historic district, and a new 12-story residential building. It flags the item as a “Residents Right to Know” item under the city code.

Why a taller building is allowed here

The site sits in the Ocean Beach Historic District, south of Fifth Street. The letter says the zoning there does not normally allow buildings taller than 100 feet.

Voters approved a bonus for hotels that switch to housing in this zoning district in 2022. The letter puts the yes vote at 65.66%. The city then wrote the bonus into its code in 2023 and added the extra height in 2024.

Under the code section quoted in the letter, an owner who takes the bonus must:

  • turn the property into homes for good, with no hotel, hostel or suite-hotel use
  • sign a covenant that no unit is ever rented for less than six months and one day
  • keep any historic building on the site, as the preservation board approves
  • win the board’s approval by Dec. 31, 2027, and get a full building permit by June 30, 2030

The letter says the owner has sent the city a draft of that covenant.

The one exception it asks for

The owner is asking for a variance so balconies on the north side can stick out 8 feet. The code allows 4 feet 10 inches there. The letter argues that the taller tower has to sit farther back from the historic building, which shrinks the room for balconies. It says the balconies would face the park and no neighboring building.

The filings do not say when the hotel would close or when work would start.

The plan is separate from the city’s move to sue the state over the Savoy and the Arlington on the 400 block of Ocean Drive, where the fight is over a state law on demolishing oceanfront buildings.

What it means for you

  • The board meets at 9 a.m. Tuesday, Dec. 15, in the City Commission chambers at City Hall, 1700 Convention Center Drive, and on Zoom (webinar ID 817 4834 7488). The Dec. 15 agenda lists it as item 2 under new applications and links the plans and reports.
  • The agenda sets aside time to swear in members of the public who want to speak. Board items are sometimes continued to a later meeting, so check the agenda the week before.